Restraint of Trade Clauses Explained: What They Mean for Employees and Employers
You've accepted a new job, or you're selling your business, and the contract contains a clause saying you can't compete, poach clients or work in your field for a set time. That's a restraint of trade clause and it can have a big impact on your freedom to earn a living or protect what you've built. Here's a plain-English explanation of what these clauses mean for both employees and employers.
What is a restraint of trade?
A restraint of trade is a contract term that limits a person's freedom to carry on their trade, business or profession. As the Cornell Law School Legal Information Institute describes it, a restraint of trade is broadly any activity that tends to limit a party's ability to enter into transactions. In an employment or business-sale setting, it usually shows up as one of a few common clause types.
The main types of restraint clauses
- Non-compete stops a person from working for a competitor or starting a competing business for a period and within an area.
- Non-solicitation of clients stops a person from approaching or poaching the business's clients or customers.
- Non-solicitation of staff stops a person from recruiting former colleagues away from the business.
- Confidentiality protects trade secrets and confidential information (often ongoing).
The key tension: protection vs freedom
Restraint clauses sit on a fault line. Employers have a legitimate interest in protecting confidential information, client relationships and goodwill. Workers have a competing interest in being able to earn a living and move freely between jobs.
Because of that tension, courts in many countries treat broad restraints with caution and the starting position in a number of jurisdictions is that a restraint of trade is unenforceable unless it goes no further than is reasonably necessary to protect a legitimate business interest.
What makes a restraint enforceable (or not)
While the law varies widely between countries, the common theme is reasonableness. Courts typically look at:
- Duration how long the restriction lasts. Shorter is more likely to be upheld.
- Geographic area how wide the no-go zone is. It should match where the business actually operates.
- Scope of activity what exactly the person is barred from doing.
- Legitimate interest is there a genuine interest (like client goodwill or trade secrets) being protected, or is it just stifling competition?
A clause that is too long, too wide or too broad risks being cut down or struck out entirely.
What each side should do
Employers: Draft restraints that are specific and no wider than needed an overreaching clause is more likely to fail. Tailor the duration and area to the real risk.
Employees: Before signing, understand what you're agreeing to and how it could limit your next move. Before breaching one, get advice some restraints are enforceable, and the consequences can be serious.
The bottom line
A restraint of trade clause balances an employer's right to protect its business against a worker's right to earn a living, and enforceability almost always turns on whether the restriction is reasonable. Because the rules differ dramatically between countries some heavily restrict these clauses, others enforce reasonable ones this is general information, not legal advice.
Whether you're drafting a restraint or weighing one you've been asked to sign, it pays to have it reviewed by a commercial law specialist: https://dfglegal.com.au/service/commercial-law/